
November 18, 2026
America must not repeat Europe's mistakes.
In his recent essay, Tal Fortgang rightly urges American Jews to confront the rise of Islamism. He raises several uncomfortable questions that many in polite society would rather not address. How should a constitutional republic confront an extreme religious and political ideology that explicitly targets the Jewish people? How can a society so utterly obsessed with political correctness distinguish between genuine pluralism and outright surrender, coexistence and concession? And what happens when those who raise legitimate concerns are publicly and ruthlessly condemned?
These are vital questions. But I believe we need to take them further.
The United States was founded at the intersection of Jerusalem, Athens, and Rome. Judeo-Christian values form its moral and legal bedrock, and Enlightenment ideas form its intellectual foundation. Together, these ideas forged the American experiment: a constitutional republic based on the radical proposition that human beings possess certain inalienable rights that no government can legitimately abridge.

November 18, 2026
America must not repeat Europe's mistakes.
In his recent essay, Tal Fortgang rightly urges American Jews to confront the rise of Islamism. He raises several uncomfortable questions that many in polite society would rather not address. How should a constitutional republic confront an extreme religious and political ideology that explicitly targets the Jewish people? How can a society so utterly obsessed with political correctness distinguish between genuine pluralism and outright surrender, coexistence and concession? And what happens when those who raise legitimate concerns are publicly and ruthlessly condemned?
These are vital questions. But I believe we need to take them further.
The United States was founded at the intersection of Jerusalem, Athens, and Rome. Judeo-Christian values form its moral and legal bedrock, and Enlightenment ideas form its intellectual foundation. Together, these ideas forged the American experiment: a constitutional republic based on the radical proposition that human beings possess certain inalienable rights that no government can legitimately abridge.
Unlock the most serious Jewish, Zionist, and American thinking.
Subscribe NowIn his recent essay, Tal Fortgang rightly urges American Jews to confront the rise of Islamism. He raises several uncomfortable questions that many in polite society would rather not address. How should a constitutional republic confront an extreme religious and political ideology that explicitly targets the Jewish people? How can a society so utterly obsessed with political correctness distinguish between genuine pluralism and outright surrender, coexistence and concession? And what happens when those who raise legitimate concerns are publicly and ruthlessly condemned?
These are vital questions. But I believe we need to take them further.
The United States was founded at the intersection of Jerusalem, Athens, and Rome. Judeo-Christian values form its moral and legal bedrock, and Enlightenment ideas form its intellectual foundation. Together, these ideas forged the American experiment: a constitutional republic based on the radical proposition that human beings possess certain inalienable rights that no government can legitimately abridge.
Get the best Jewish ideas and conversations. $10/month.
Subscribe nowAlready subscribed? Sign in