About the Author
Ayaan Hirsi Ali is the founder of the AHA Foundation and a fellow at the Hoover Institute. She was born in Somalia, is now a United States citizen, and is a recent convert to Christianity.

November 18, 2026
America must not repeat Europe's mistakes.
In his recent essay, Tal Fortgang rightly urges American Jews to confront the rise of Islamism. He raises several uncomfortable questions that many in polite society would rather not address. How should a constitutional republic confront an extreme religious and political ideology that explicitly targets the Jewish people? How can a society so utterly obsessed with political correctness distinguish between genuine pluralism and outright surrender, coexistence and concession? And what happens when those who raise legitimate concerns are publicly and ruthlessly condemned?
These are vital questions. But I believe we need to take them further.
The United States was founded at the intersection of Jerusalem, Athens, and Rome. Judeo-Christian values form its moral and legal bedrock, and Enlightenment ideas form its intellectual foundation. Together, these ideas forged the American experiment: a constitutional republic based on the radical proposition that human beings possess certain inalienable rights that no government can legitimately abridge.

November 18, 2026
America must not repeat Europe's mistakes.
In his recent essay, Tal Fortgang rightly urges American Jews to confront the rise of Islamism. He raises several uncomfortable questions that many in polite society would rather not address. How should a constitutional republic confront an extreme religious and political ideology that explicitly targets the Jewish people? How can a society so utterly obsessed with political correctness distinguish between genuine pluralism and outright surrender, coexistence and concession? And what happens when those who raise legitimate concerns are publicly and ruthlessly condemned?
These are vital questions. But I believe we need to take them further.
The United States was founded at the intersection of Jerusalem, Athens, and Rome. Judeo-Christian values form its moral and legal bedrock, and Enlightenment ideas form its intellectual foundation. Together, these ideas forged the American experiment: a constitutional republic based on the radical proposition that human beings possess certain inalienable rights that no government can legitimately abridge.
Unlock the most serious Jewish, Zionist, and American thinking.
Subscribe NowIn his recent essay, Tal Fortgang rightly urges American Jews to confront the rise of Islamism. He raises several uncomfortable questions that many in polite society would rather not address. How should a constitutional republic confront an extreme religious and political ideology that explicitly targets the Jewish people? How can a society so utterly obsessed with political correctness distinguish between genuine pluralism and outright surrender, coexistence and concession? And what happens when those who raise legitimate concerns are publicly and ruthlessly condemned?
These are vital questions. But I believe we need to take them further.
The United States was founded at the intersection of Jerusalem, Athens, and Rome. Judeo-Christian values form its moral and legal bedrock, and Enlightenment ideas form its intellectual foundation. Together, these ideas forged the American experiment: a constitutional republic based on the radical proposition that human beings possess certain inalienable rights that no government can legitimately abridge.
These rights are the direct fruit of Judeo-Christian civilization’s most revolutionary idea: Imago Dei, the conviction that every human being is created in the image and likeness of God, and is therefore endowed with inherent and inviolable dignity and worth.
From this theological foundation springs the idea that human rights do not belong to governments or majorities to dispense or deny as they see fit. Rather, rights belong to every individual and exist before, and above, any social contract. This revolutionary idea, utterly alien to most cultures and civilizations, gave rise to the Western ideas of freedom of conscience, equality before the law, religious liberty, and limited government.
But these foundational ideas, central to Judeo-Christian civilization and the West more broadly, are under siege today. They are threatened by a rising tide of Islamist thought and politics. Islamism, the project of organizing all aspects of life in accordance with an uncompromising understanding of Sharia, is fundamentally at odds with liberal democracy. In its classic expression, Sharia rejects freedom of conscience. Its inheritance and family law treat women unequally, and it denies women’s basic rights in other ways. Non-Muslims receive markedly different treatment from Muslims under Sharia.
These ideas stand in stark contrast to the American tradition, and to the values of freedom, equality, and individual rights on which the American experiment was founded. Fortgang is correct to call upon American Jews to speak out against the growing influence of Islamism in the West, and against the moral cowardice that allows it to flourish.
This call to action should resonate beyond the Jewish community, however. What is at stake in this debate is not the fate of one ethnic or religious community vis-à-vis another. It is the future of individual rights, and the principles that underpin free societies—and, ultimately, the survival of Western civilization itself.
Fortgang’s essay rightly challenges the facile and dangerous tendency, particularly common among Western elites, to collapse any criticism of an idea into bigotry against the people with whom that idea is associated. Many, I am sure, may feel that distinguishing among the terms Islam, Muslims, and Islamism is unnecessary, since their definitions are already well understood. But in practice, failing to draw these lines is precisely what paralyzes Western intellectual clarity.
Islam is the sum total of religious and legal traditions, commentaries, and interpretations that have arisen within the world’s second-largest religion. As with any religious or philosophical tradition, ideas within the Islamic canon are amenable to analysis and critique. Muslims, for their part, are the adherents of this religion, billions of individuals, united by a common faith, but hardly a monolith. Some Muslims are devout, some are secular; some are reform-minded, others are traditionalists; and many, like most people anywhere, simply wish to go about their daily lives, raising families, pursuing vocations, and practicing their religion, without interference from either mosque or state. Islamism, a family of political ideologies united by their aspiration to reshape society and the state in accordance with their interpretation of ideologically hostile teachings, is the most potent threat.
The three are entirely interconnected, but they are not interchangeable. Confusing them, or suggesting that criticizing one demonizes the others, does a disservice to clear-eyed analysis of each. And it betrays the values on which Western civilization was founded. In a society truly committed to freedom of expression and religion, no ideas or communities can be off-limits. No person or group of people should enjoy a special dispensation from critique, much less be elevated to the status of untouchable arbiters of acceptable discourse.
This principle is especially important in the context of Islam and Islamism, given the latter’s authoritarian bent and its frequent targeting of Muslim dissidents and apostates. Many Muslims themselves wish to see change within their own religion. But in too many instances, governments and other Western institutions have chosen to empower precisely those Muslim organizations most amenable to Islamist ideas, effectively anointing them as the official voice of Islam and Muslims in the West. In so doing, they have effectively given their imprimatur to the ideas most at odds with religious and intellectual freedom, and most threatening to apostates, secular Muslims, and other Muslim dissidents.
The result has been the elevation of Islamist ideas and organizations at the expense of free expression and religious liberty more broadly in academia, in municipal politics, and other consequential spheres. Far from promoting greater religious and cultural understanding, this dynamic has instead served to entrench the most theologically and socially conservative expressions of Islam, and to marginalize more pluralistic voices. It has emboldened would-be censors, giving them the cover of officialdom with which to threaten critics of Islam with accusations of racism and bigotry. And it has given voice to those elements within the Muslim community most hostile to the philosophies and principles that I, and I suspect most readers, hold dear. That voice is growing louder by the day.
As the Muslim population increases in the United States, and more radical forms of Islam begin to take root, the West faces a decisive test of its own moral conviction. Capitulation in the name of multiculturalism should not be confused with true pluralism. Far from promoting harmony among different religious and ethnic communities, multiculturalism has resulted in an abdication, particularly in Europe, of social and political responsibility and thus the empowerment of parallel legal and social systems that operate outside of, and often in defiance of, the state. Far from promoting religious or cultural understanding, policies adopted in the name of sensitivity have given rise to a series of enclaves in which the rule of law yields to religious or ethnic custom, and in which all who reject Islam, be they Jewish, Christian, or atheist, suffer the consequences of a system that prioritizes a form of theocratic tribalism above freedom of conscience and individual rights.
The end product—from Berlin to Brussels, London to Lens—has been the growing sway of Islamists, who view multiculturalism as an opportunity to advance their goal of an Islamic renaissance, and to delegitimize critiques of barbaric doctrines as either misinformed or outright hateful. It has also done little to advance the cause of integration among Muslim immigrants, who find themselves caught between increasingly brazen Islamists on the one hand and a culture of performative tolerance on the other that greets any critique of their belief system with cries of racism. Europe has served as the testing ground for this failure; America would do well to learn from its mistakes.
If Western governments, including the United States, truly wish to promote pluralism and integration, they should make clear that all religious and ethnic organizations operating within their borders do so at the state’s sufferance and under the jurisdiction of its laws. They should also make clear that no individual or organization is beyond the reach of the courts or legitimate criticism. Seventh-century savageries have no place dictating the terms of 21st-century Western liberty, especially not in the United States.
Above all, Western governments must make clear that when communal custom conflicts with a country’s established legal framework, the latter prevails. This principle, once so self-evident as to go without saying, faces increasing challenge from opportunists and extremists who seek to carve out unearned and inexcusable exceptions in the name of religious or cultural entitlement.
The challenges facing the United States and its Western allies in this regard are considerable. To be clear, the threats facing the Jewish population—particularly American Jews—are incredibly serious and in many ways existential. I will never know what it is like to be targeted specifically for being Jewish. But I do know what it is like to be raised under Islam and the price one pays for rejecting its authority and daring to break away. The dangers facing Jews are significant, perhaps more so now than at any other point in recent history. But the dangers extend beyond the Jewish community, threatening the tens of millions of Christians who cherish the principles and traditions on which this great country was built. Jews and Christians are united by our belief in human dignity, justice, and fairness; personal responsibility and free will; democratic values; the sanctity of family; and the principles of forgiveness and mercy. The Jewish fight is the Christian fight, and what harms one harms the other. Together, we must confront the totalizing threat of Islamism. We must reject the self-harming effects of moral posturing and cowardly appeasement. Most of all, we must aggressively defend the constitutional order that safeguards our freedom. The influence of Islamism is growing; our response must match its ambition and determination, in America and beyond.
Ayaan Hirsi Ali is the founder of the AHA Foundation and a fellow at the Hoover Institute. She was born in Somalia, is now a United States citizen, and is a recent convert to Christianity.