Tikvah
Editors’ Pick

October 23, 2026

A Rabbinic Court Case Presses the Limits of Religious Freedom

Why the Supreme Court was asked to intervene.

When observant Jews have a civil dispute, they are required by halakhah to take it to a rabbinic court or beit din. The American legal system generally upholds the decisions of these courts as it would any binding arbitration. But sometimes things go wrong and state and federal courts are asked to step in. A complex litigation involving two civil courts and three rabbinic ones led to a federal judge’s forceful intervention; in response, one party, Samuel Strulovich, appealed that decision to the Supreme Court. Michael A. Helfand and Chaim Saiman write:

SaveGift