While Islamic Jihad Launches Rockets at Israel, Hamas Faces a Dilemma
One wants quiet, the other to “engage the enemy.”
November 13, 2019
In the U.S., Jews, too, have absorbed Protestant individualism.
According to the conventional wisdom on the American Jewish left, Israel’s continued presence in the West Bank, together with the policies of the Likud, have alienated U.S. Jewry from the Jewish state. The Israeli right, too, has its own variation on this narrative—namely, that American Jews can’t possibly understand the security challenges Israelis face. In Divided We Stand, Daniel Gordis argues that the profound differences between the two Jewries go back a century and revolve around issues far more fundamental than conventional wisdom assumes. Haviv Rettig Gur suggests an additional explanation for Jewry’s great divide:
One wants quiet, the other to “engage the enemy.”
As Soviet history shows, it’s an approach that’s bound to fail.
In the U.S., Jews, too, have absorbed Protestant individualism.
Even after taking the Orthodox out of the picture.
When Jews in France were being persecuted, the pope protected those in Carpentras.
According to the conventional wisdom on the American Jewish left, Israel’s continued presence in the West Bank, together with the policies of the Likud, have alienated U.S. Jewry from the Jewish state. The Israeli right, too, has its own variation on this narrative—namely, that American Jews can’t possibly understand the security challenges Israelis face. In Divided We Stand, Daniel Gordis argues that the profound differences between the two Jewries go back a century and revolve around issues far more fundamental than conventional wisdom assumes. Haviv Rettig Gur suggests an additional explanation for Jewry’s great divide:
Unlock the most serious Jewish, Zionist, and American thinking.
Subscribe Now