
November 19, 2026
A democratic republic has the right to decide, on any grounds it wishes, whom it will admit to citizenship.
Tal Fortgang has written a patriotic essay that calls on readers to re-examine a patriotic platitude. Immigration has enriched the United States, Fortgang grants—but 21st-century mass immigration may be different. Making their appearance in Western Europe after World War II for the first time in half a millennium, Muslim communities have grown steadily since the early 1960s, and have proved hard to absorb into Christian and post-Christian ones. Does that tell us something about the United States? Since the turn of this century its Muslim population has grown at an incredible rate, more than doubling to roughly 5 million. Citing incidents of violence committed by Muslims against Jews in the United States and the role of Muslims in fomenting skepticism about American support for the state of Israel, Fortgang urges Jews to consider more than the size of immigration flows. The culture of America’s immigrants is a critical matter, one that, in this case, has the potential to affect Jews’ “physical security, their electoral standing, the American alliance with Israel, and, more broadly, the civic order from which they have benefited greatly.” Fortgang’s view sits uneasily with both American immigration law and a historically understandable Jewish optimism about the power of America to transform migrants.
A democratic republic has the right to decide, on any grounds it wishes, whom it will admit to citizenship, and its own citizens are responsible for those decisions. “We Jews,” writes Fortgang, “are allowed to advocate policies that redound to our benefit.” In all of this, he is aligned with the understanding of borders that prevailed throughout the West up until 1965. Even Immanuel Kant, as he developed his notion that humans were Weltbürger, or “citizens of the world,” made explicit that they did not thereby have the right to be citizens of any country they chose. That required an explicit authorization by the natives.
But since 1965, only part of our country has believed this. That year, in introducing a reform of the country-specific immigration regime that had prevailed for the preceding four decades, President Lyndon Johnson not only renounced but denounced the idea of preferring immigrants from certain places. He called it “a cruel and enduring wrong in the conduct of the American Nation.” In so opining, Johnson risked undermining the idea of the United States as a nation altogether. Henceforth, where Americans got their immigrants from would be determined not by the advantage to Americans but by the fluctuating opinions and ambitions of foreigners.

November 19, 2026
A democratic republic has the right to decide, on any grounds it wishes, whom it will admit to citizenship.
Tal Fortgang has written a patriotic essay that calls on readers to re-examine a patriotic platitude. Immigration has enriched the United States, Fortgang grants—but 21st-century mass immigration may be different. Making their appearance in Western Europe after World War II for the first time in half a millennium, Muslim communities have grown steadily since the early 1960s, and have proved hard to absorb into Christian and post-Christian ones. Does that tell us something about the United States? Since the turn of this century its Muslim population has grown at an incredible rate, more than doubling to roughly 5 million. Citing incidents of violence committed by Muslims against Jews in the United States and the role of Muslims in fomenting skepticism about American support for the state of Israel, Fortgang urges Jews to consider more than the size of immigration flows. The culture of America’s immigrants is a critical matter, one that, in this case, has the potential to affect Jews’ “physical security, their electoral standing, the American alliance with Israel, and, more broadly, the civic order from which they have benefited greatly.” Fortgang’s view sits uneasily with both American immigration law and a historically understandable Jewish optimism about the power of America to transform migrants.
A democratic republic has the right to decide, on any grounds it wishes, whom it will admit to citizenship, and its own citizens are responsible for those decisions. “We Jews,” writes Fortgang, “are allowed to advocate policies that redound to our benefit.” In all of this, he is aligned with the understanding of borders that prevailed throughout the West up until 1965. Even Immanuel Kant, as he developed his notion that humans were Weltbürger, or “citizens of the world,” made explicit that they did not thereby have the right to be citizens of any country they chose. That required an explicit authorization by the natives.
But since 1965, only part of our country has believed this. That year, in introducing a reform of the country-specific immigration regime that had prevailed for the preceding four decades, President Lyndon Johnson not only renounced but denounced the idea of preferring immigrants from certain places. He called it “a cruel and enduring wrong in the conduct of the American Nation.” In so opining, Johnson risked undermining the idea of the United States as a nation altogether. Henceforth, where Americans got their immigrants from would be determined not by the advantage to Americans but by the fluctuating opinions and ambitions of foreigners.
Unlock the most serious Jewish, Zionist, and American thinking.
Subscribe NowTal Fortgang has written a patriotic essay that calls on readers to re-examine a patriotic platitude. Immigration has enriched the United States, Fortgang grants—but 21st-century mass immigration may be different. Making their appearance in Western Europe after World War II for the first time in half a millennium, Muslim communities have grown steadily since the early 1960s, and have proved hard to absorb into Christian and post-Christian ones. Does that tell us something about the United States? Since the turn of this century its Muslim population has grown at an incredible rate, more than doubling to roughly 5 million. Citing incidents of violence committed by Muslims against Jews in the United States and the role of Muslims in fomenting skepticism about American support for the state of Israel, Fortgang urges Jews to consider more than the size of immigration flows. The culture of America’s immigrants is a critical matter, one that, in this case, has the potential to affect Jews’ “physical security, their electoral standing, the American alliance with Israel, and, more broadly, the civic order from which they have benefited greatly.” Fortgang’s view sits uneasily with both American immigration law and a historically understandable Jewish optimism about the power of America to transform migrants.
A democratic republic has the right to decide, on any grounds it wishes, whom it will admit to citizenship, and its own citizens are responsible for those decisions. “We Jews,” writes Fortgang, “are allowed to advocate policies that redound to our benefit.” In all of this, he is aligned with the understanding of borders that prevailed throughout the West up until 1965. Even Immanuel Kant, as he developed his notion that humans were Weltbürger, or “citizens of the world,” made explicit that they did not thereby have the right to be citizens of any country they chose. That required an explicit authorization by the natives.
But since 1965, only part of our country has believed this. That year, in introducing a reform of the country-specific immigration regime that had prevailed for the preceding four decades, President Lyndon Johnson not only renounced but denounced the idea of preferring immigrants from certain places. He called it “a cruel and enduring wrong in the conduct of the American Nation.” In so opining, Johnson risked undermining the idea of the United States as a nation altogether. Henceforth, where Americans got their immigrants from would be determined not by the advantage to Americans but by the fluctuating opinions and ambitions of foreigners.
Get the best Jewish ideas and conversations. $10/month.
Subscribe nowAlready subscribed? Sign in