Tikvah
Editors’ Pick

September 15, 2020

Pop Culture Embraces Tradition, While Tradition Embraces Pop Culture—but Only One Succeeds

American Pickle and Young Rechnitz

In American Pickle­—the latest vehicle for the actor Seth Rogen—a Brooklyn Jewish slacker encounters his shtetl-born great-grandfather Herschel through a plot twist reminiscent of Rip van Winkle or Woody Allen’s Sleeper. The younger character eventually comes to appreciate the wisdom and power of Herschel’s traditional religiosity. “In theory,” writes Liel Leibovitz, such a plot “should delight anyone hankering for a movie that takes faith seriously.” In practice, however, it falls flat:

SaveGift