Solving the Mystery of the Syria’s New Ruler
Neither a peacemaker nor a jihadist in disguise.
August 17, 2026
Neither a peacemaker nor a jihadist in disguise.
Since Ahmad al-Sharaa led his militia—which began its life as the Syrian branch of al-Qaeda—to victory over Bashar al-Assad, Israelis, American policymakers, and informed observers have debated whether he should be seen as a diehard jihadist willing to play nice, a Turkish cat’s paw, or a leader trying to move his country in the right direction who should be welcomed by the West. Michael Milshtein tries to make sense of both the new regime, “a mystery that has become a strategic dilemma for Israel,” and the discussion about it that has recently resurface in the Israeli press:
Neither a peacemaker nor a jihadist in disguise.
Enforcing the law in Judea and Samaria.
Giving a kosher stamp to anti-Israel propaganda.
“The moral lever of humanity.”
Keep silent and hear.
Since Ahmad al-Sharaa led his militia—which began its life as the Syrian branch of al-Qaeda—to victory over Bashar al-Assad, Israelis, American policymakers, and informed observers have debated whether he should be seen as a diehard jihadist willing to play nice, a Turkish cat’s paw, or a leader trying to move his country in the right direction who should be welcomed by the West. Michael Milshtein tries to make sense of both the new regime, “a mystery that has become a strategic dilemma for Israel,” and the discussion about it that has recently resurface in the Israeli press:
Get the best Jewish ideas and conversations. $10/month.
Subscribe nowAlready subscribed? Sign in
Unlock the most serious Jewish, Zionist, and American thinking.
Subscribe Now