The Internal Hamas Squabbles That Are Making Negotiations Harder
Both factions agree that Israel must be destroyed, but they disagree about Hamas’s current prospects.
July 21, 2025
Reminisces of Yasir Arafat and Edward Said’s nephew.
In the late 1980s, Jonathan Torop, a pro-Israel American Jew, befriended Ussama Makdisi, the son of a Lebanese father and Palestinian mother and the nephew of Edward Said. Makdisi is now a professor at the University of California, Berkeley, and his comment, after the Hamas invasion of southern Israel—“I could have been one of those who broke the siege on October 7”—was brought up at the recent congressional hearings. Torop recollects the time when he and Makdisi could look beyond their political differences:
Both factions agree that Israel must be destroyed, but they disagree about Hamas’s current prospects.
While the world sits silent, Jerusalem steps in to save the Druze.
Reminisces of Yasir Arafat and Edward Said’s nephew.
A lesson in Jewish political assertiveness.
Johannes Jablonski.
In the late 1980s, Jonathan Torop, a pro-Israel American Jew, befriended Ussama Makdisi, the son of a Lebanese father and Palestinian mother and the nephew of Edward Said. Makdisi is now a professor at the University of California, Berkeley, and his comment, after the Hamas invasion of southern Israel—“I could have been one of those who broke the siege on October 7”—was brought up at the recent congressional hearings. Torop recollects the time when he and Makdisi could look beyond their political differences:
Unlock the most serious Jewish, Zionist, and American thinking.
Subscribe Now